Giovanni's New York Pizza

4.2 (302 reviews )
$$
Pizza restaurant
Outdoor seating
Delivery
Drive-through
Takeout
+(16)

About Giovanni's New York Pizza

Giovanni's New York Pizza, located at 134 Eagle School Rd in Martinsburg, WV, captures the essence of classic American dining with a delightful twist. The restaurant is celebrated for its authentic New York-style pizza, featuring a perfectly crisp fold and gooey cheese pull, alongside a diverse menu that includes mouthwatering meatball subs, juicy cheesesteaks, and even a cauliflower crust option for health-conscious diners. Customers rave about the warm, friendly service and nostalgic TMNT theme, creating an inviting atmosphere. With a commitment to quality and flavor, Giovanni's stands out as a beloved local gem that promises satisfaction with every bite.

Reviews (302) 4.2

  • Harrison Nelms
    Jul 22,2025

    First time here and dig the TMNT and Coke theme, feels very classically American. They weren't happy with how my pizza cooked ( I was very happy with it, so delicious!) so I get to take this one home. Sweet tea here is superb and the hot dogs were loved by my kids, and my wife polished off her meatball sub. Everything we got we loved and we were treated extremely well!

  • Lady Jays Catering Service, LLC
    Jul 22,2025

    I ordered the Meatlovers Cauliflower Crust Pizza and it is the BEST pizza I’ve ever had! OH MY GOODNESS! So so good, didn’t spike my blood sugar, super fresh and super delicious! So happy to have found a place where I can enjoy pizza while being diabetic! Thank you so much, also my mom raves about your chicken cheesesteak sub! We will definitely be back! God bless and I wish you a successful and prosperous 2024!

  • Ben Rylander
    Jul 22,2025

    Chris, and Carol were awesome. First time there, won’t be our last time. Pizza was amazing for the price. Better than your “pizza huts, dominos” for sure. Love the TMNT theme lol.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are some popular dishes at Giovanni's New York Pizza?

    Customers rave about the meat lovers cauliflower crust pizza, cheesesteaks, and the classic pizza slices. Don't forget to try their delicious ice cream and sweet tea!

  • Can I make a reservation or should I just walk in?

    You can make a reservation if you'd like, but walk-ins are always welcome. It's a casual spot, so feel free to stop by anytime!

  • What dining options are available at Giovanni's?

    Giovanni's offers a variety of dining options including dine-in, takeout, and drive-through services. You can enjoy your meal outside on the patio as well.

  • What is the atmosphere like and when is the best time to visit?

    Giovanni's has a casual and family-friendly atmosphere, great for solo dining or groups. It's quieter during the earlier hours, so visiting for lunch might be a good idea!

  • What amenities are provided, especially for families?

    The restaurant is very family-friendly, with amenities like high chairs, kids' menus, and changing tables. There's also plenty of parking, including wheelchair accessible options.

Nearby Pizza restaurants

Pizza restaurant
East of Chicago Pizza of Shinnston

343 S Pike St, Shinnston, WV 26431, United States

Pizza restaurant
Four B's Pizza & Subs

15691 Northwestern Turnpike, Augusta, WV 26704, United States

Pizza restaurant
Gino's Pizza & Spaghetti House

286 E Main St, Milton, WV 25541, United States

Pizza restaurant
Zappers

2559 Ritter Dr, Shady Spring, WV 25918, United States

Pizza restaurant
Dicarlo's Original Pizza

523 Commerce St Wellsburg, WV 26070 United States

Pizza restaurant
Chunki's Pizza

341 E Pike St Clarksburg, WV 26301

Are you the owner?

Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.

Claim this page Claim this page